The best chili is a careful balancing act creating a chili that is spicy but not too spicy.
I'm sure we have all been a little too heavy-handed in our seasoning from time to time. In fact, it is easier to accidentally over spice dishes like chili that typically have a long-simmering time. When simmered for a long time liquid evaporates concentrating the flavors in the dish.
But don't worry if your chili turned out too spicy, it can be saved.
If you want a tried and true chili recipe with carefully measured spices try my recipe for Hearty Crock Pot Chili.
This page may contain affiliate links. I only recommend products that I would use myself. I may earn a small commission when you make purchases through these links at no additional cost to you. Thank you. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information please read my Disclosure Policy.
Here are some of the best ways to salvage chili that is too spicy.
Capsaicin is the chemical compound in chiles that make them taste spicy. One of the best ways to counteract capsaicin is to add some dairy. Dairy contains casein that binds with the capsaicin and neutralizes it.
Popular sources of dairy for chili usually comes in the form of toppings. Try topping your chili with sour cream, Greek yogurt, and/or cheese to tone down the spice level.
2. Add a Potato or Two
Add a couple of peeled russet potatoes to the chili. The potatoes will soak up liquid along with some of the spice as they cook. Because they soak up so much liquid and will release starch as they cook you may need to add additional liquid to the chili.
Remove the potatoes from the chili before serving, but don't throw them away. Mash them with some butter and cream to make some delicious chili mashed potatoes.
Sugar also helps to neutralize the heat from capsaicin. Try adding a little sugar, honey, or tomato sauce (which is high in sugar) to balance out too spicy chili. You could also try adding some caramelized onions which will add natural sweetness along with another layer of flavor.
4. Add Additional Ingredients
Add additional tomatoes and/or beans to your chili. Increasing the volume of your chili will help to diffuse the spice.
5. Pair Chili with a Starch
Starch's neutral flavor will help to counterbalance the chili's spice. One of my favorite ways to serve chili is over a bed of cooked pasta. You could also serve too spicy chili with macaroni and cheese which has the added bonus of introducing some dairy as well.
Potatoes are also a delicious complement to spicy chili. Spoon chili over a baked russet potato.
6. Add Fat
Adding additional fat to your chili will also tame its spice level. One of my favorite high-fat additions for chili is avocadoes. Mash one up and stir it into your chili or dice the avocado and add it as a garnish to individual bowls of chili.
7. Add Acid
Acids are great at cutting through too much spice. Capsaicin is alkaline, meaning it has a high pH number. By adding acids that are lower on the pH scale the two ingredients will neutralize each other.
A little acid will go a long way. Slowly add the acid in small additions tasting as you go.
The obvious acidic addition to chili would be additional tomatoes or tomato paste.
Other options include:
- Lemon or lime juice
- Vinegar (red, white, or apple cider)
How not to cool down spicy chili
- Don't add additional water to the chili. Capsaicin is an oil and everyone knows oil and water do not mix. The only thing additional water will do is make your chili watery.
- Don't add anything carbonated like beer. The bubbly sensation that comes from carbonated beverages will only increase the burning feeling in your mouth.
The best way to tone down too spicy chili is to add additional ingredients that either compliment and/or cut through the spiciness, such as dairy, sugar, fat, or acid.