Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies with Chocolate Chips (How I Met Your Mother Cookies)

These Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies with Chocolate Chips are soft chewy peanut butter cookies studded with chocolate chips and filled with caramel.

Peanut Butter + Chocolate Chips+ Chewy Caramels!

They are soft and chewy in the middle with surprise gooey centers of caramel and crispy edges.

These are a real crowd-pleaser and one of my favorite cookies to bring to cookie exchanges.

This is probably the most delicious cookie recipe on my blog! This is saying something because I love cookies and have written several recipes. A close second is these Salted Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookies.

Chewy cookies are my favorite type of cookie. If they are yours too you will want to try these Fresh Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies, Nutella Brownie Cookies, Bacon Bourbon Chocolate Chip Cookies, Condensed Milk Chocolate Chip Cookies, or these Sourdough Snickerdoodles.

This page may contain affiliate links. I only recommend products that I would use myself. I may earn a small commission when you make purchases through these links at no additional cost to you. Thank you. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information please read my Disclosure Policy.

Why You Will Love This Recipe

• These caramel peanut butter cookies combine three of the best ingredients peanut butter, chocolate, and a gooey caramel center.
• These chewy cookies are the perfect combination of sweet and salty.
• Like most chocolate chip cookies these amazing cookies freeze really well. Mix up a batch and freeze them so that you can enjoy a freshly baked cookie or two anytime.

Why Are These Cookies Nicknamed Sumbitch Cookies?

It is from the TV show "How I Met Your Mother." Which is where I got the inspiration to bake these cookies. By the way, if you haven't seen this show before you should really check it out. It is one of my absolute favorites.

In the final season episode, The Locket (S9E1), Tracy Mosby (Cristin Milioti), Ted's future wife, calms an agitated Lily Aldrin (Alyson Hannigan) by offering her a cookie when they meet on the train to Farhampton. Both women, unknown to each other, dubbed the cookies “sumbitches” because the combination of peanut butter, chocolate chips, and caramel was so good.

Ingredients

Bread Flour: Bread Flour has a higher protein content which results in a chewier cookie.

Kosher Salt: I prefer to bake with Kosher salt, Morton brand specifically. If you use Diamond Kosher salt it is less salty than Morton and you will need to double the amount.

Baking Soda: Provides the leavening for the cookies.

Butter: Room temperature butter is easier to cream together with the sugar. I use unsalted butter. If you only have salted butter you will need to omit the salt in the recipe. There is about ¼ teaspoon of salt per stick of salted butter.

Creamy Peanut Butter: Smooth peanut butter replaces some of the butter in these cookies to add its nutty salty flavor.

Brown and White Sugar: This recipe uses both types of sugar. The brown sugar adds moisture while the white sugar helps the cookie dough spread while it is baking.

Egg + Egg Yolk: Eggs should be at room temperature. The additional egg yolk adds extra richness and fat which results in a softer cookie.

Vanilla: When baking I prefer pure vanilla extract rather than imitation.

Mini Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips: You could use regular chocolate chips or chopped semi-sweet chocolate, but I found mini chocolate chips easier to use when wrapping dough around pieces of caramel.

Caramels: My favorite caramels for stuffing into cookies are Werther’s Original Soft Caramels. They have just the right texture and melt beautifully. You could also use other brands of soft caramels, Rolo candies, or any other caramel-filled candy bar like Snickers or Milky Way. I recommend cutting each caramel in half to prevent molten caramel from erupting while the cookies bake,

Equipment

Kitchen scale: Kitchen scales make baking faster and neater. Accuracy matters in baking. Scales are more precise than measuring cups. Too much flour or not enough sugar can dramatically change a recipe. The most accurate way to bake is to measure your ingredients by weight rather than volume.

A kitchen scale also reduces the number of dishes you will need to wash because you are measuring each ingredient directly from the container into the mixing bowl without the use of measuring cups.

This scale from OXO is the one I use after it was recommended by Alton Brown. What makes this scale great is the display pulls out to make viewing measurements easier when using a large bowl.

Stand Mixer: I have a stand mixer from KitchenAid. My mom and brother bought it for me for my birthday almost 15 years ago. I use it weekly and it still works just like it did when it was brand new. It makes so many kitchen tasks easier and comes with a variety of attachments.

Rubber spatula: For folding batters together, I prefer a stiffer spatula like this one from OXO. It fits comfortably in my hand, is dishwasher safe, and is heat-resistant up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit. Both the handle and head are silicone coated which makes it easy to clean and safe to use with my non-stick cookware and bakeware.

My secret for perfectly baked cookies is this AirBake cookie sheet. My cookies bake evenly every time I use these pans. AirBake cookie sheets have two aluminum layers with a layer of air in between them. The layer of air decreases the temperature of the top layer of metal, preventing the bottom of the cookie from browning too quickly. These pans are also really easy to clean. Just wipe them clean with a little soap and hot water. It is not recommended to fully submerge these pans in water or place them in a dishwasher.

Directions

In the bowl of a stand mixer, cream butter, peanut butter, and sugars together with the paddle attachment on medium speed until smooth.

Lower the mixer speed to stir and add in the egg, egg yolk, and vanilla. Mix until thoroughly combined, about 30 seconds.

Stir the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients until just combined. Fold in the chocolate chips with a spatula and wrap the dough in wax paper and chill dough in the refrigerator for at least 2-3 hours.

The cookie dough needs this time for the flour to fully hydrate and the butter to solidify which will prevent the cookies from spreading too much.

While the dough is chilling unwrap the caramels and cut them in half. My favorite caramels for these cookies are Werther’s Original Soft Caramels. You could also use other brands of soft caramels, Rolo candies, or any other caramel-filled candy bar like Snickers or Milky Way.

Preheat the oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit and line a baking sheet with parchment paper.

Remove the dough from the refrigerator and roll the dough into balls, about 2 tablespoons of dough each. You’ll have about 18 balls. The dough will be a bit crumbly but will become smoother as you roll them.

Easily fill the cookies with soft caramel candies in just a few simple steps.

Break each dough ball in half and sandwich a piece of caramel between the two haves. Smooth the two halves together by rolling the dough between your hands to make a smooth ball. Make sure the caramels are completely sealed inside.

Place the cookie dough balls on the prepared baking sheet leaving at least 2 inches in between each cookie. Flatten the balls slightly with your hand to help them spread.

Bake for 10-12 minutes or until the edges are golden brown. Allow the cookies to cool for at least 10 minutes before transferring them to a wire cooling rack to cool completely.

Baking Tip: My mom's trick for evenly baked cookies is to rotate the cookies while they bake. Place the first baking sheet of cookies on the lower rack of the oven and bake until they begin to spread out (usually the same amount of time it takes me to divvy out the dough on to the second baking sheet.) Move the first baking sheet of cookies to the top rack and rotate 180-degrees to finish baking and place the second baking sheet of cookies on the bottom rack. Continue this process until all of the cookies have been baked.

Tips

• Make sure all of the ingredients are at room temperature. This ensures the ingredients mix evenly and will give you the best final texture. To quickly bring the eggs to room temperature, place the whole eggs in a bowl of warm water for 10-15 minutes.
• You could use regular chocolate chips or chopped semi-sweet chocolate, but I found mini chocolate chips easier to use when wrapping dough around pieces of caramel.
• Refrigerate the dough for 2-3 hours to allow the flour to fully hydrate and the butter to solidify which will keep the cookies from spreading too much.
• Use a cookie scoop for evenly portioned cookies. Take the guesswork out of portioning cookies by using a cookie scoop to make sure each cookie is the same size.
• Alternatively, you could cut the block of cookie dough into even pieces with a knife.
• My secret for perfectly baked cookies is this AirBake cookie sheet. My cookies bake evenly every time I use these pans. AirBake cookie sheets have two aluminum layers with a layer of air in between them. The layer of air decreases the temperature of the top layer of metal, preventing the bottom of the cookie from browning too quickly. These pans are also really easy to clean. Just wipe them clean with a little soap and hot water. It is not recommended to fully submerge these pans in water or place them in a dishwasher.
• Line the cookie sheet with parchment paper. Sometimes the caramel leaks out of the cookies. Parchment paper will make removing the cookies from the pan easier.
• Baking times for all recipes are only suggestions. The actual baking time will vary depending on your oven. It is helpful to know your oven and worth purchasing an inexpensive oven thermometer. Oven temperatures can vary as much as 50 degrees plus or minus.

Make-Ahead, Storing, and Freezing Instructions

Make-Ahead: You can mix up the cookie dough and chill it in the refrigerator for up to 3 days.

Storing: Baked cookies can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 4 days.

Freezing Cookie Dough: Unbaked cookie dough balls can be frozen for up to 3 months.

After rolling the dough into balls and stuffing them with the caramel, place them on a parchment-lined baking sheet and freeze until solid. Once frozen, remove from the baking sheet and place in a zip-top bag. Label with the date and contents.

When you are ready to bake cookies, remove the cookie balls from the freezer, let them sit at room temperature while the oven preheats, and then bake. You may need to add a minute or two to the baking time.

Freezing Baked Cookies: Baked cookies can be frozen for up to 3 months.

Once the cookies have cooled completely, place them on a sheet pan and freeze until solid. Transfer the frozen cookies to an airtight container or zip-top bag. Label with the date and contents.

Thaw frozen cookies overnight in the refrigerator or on the counter.

If you have ever struggled with dry crumbly cookie dough you will want to check out my tips on how to fix it.

Continue to Content

📖 Recipe

Yield: 24 Cookies

Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies with Chocolate Chips (How I Met Your Mother Cookies)

Print

These Peanut Butter Caramel Cookies with Chocolate Chips are soft chewy peanut butter cookies studded with chocolate chips and filled with caramel.

Prep Time 15 minutes

Cook Time 10 minutes

Additional Time 2 hours

Total Time 2 hours 25 minutes

Ingredients

• 2 ¼ cups (270g) bread flour
• ½ teaspoon kosher salt
• 1 teaspoon baking soda
• 8 tablespoons (113g) room-temperature unsalted butter
• ½ (135g) cup creamy peanut butter
• ¾ cup (150g) brown sugar
• ¼ cup (50g) sugar
• 1 egg - room temperature
• 1 egg yolk - room temperature
• 2 teaspoon vanilla
• 1 cup (170g) of mini semi-sweet chocolate chips
• 12 unwrapped caramels

Instructions

1. In a medium bowl whisk together the flour, salt, and baking soda. Set aside.
2. In the bowl of your stand mixer, cream together the butter, peanut butter, and sugars with the paddle attachment on medium speed until smooth.
3. Lower the mixer speed to stir and add in the egg, egg yolk, and vanilla. Mix until thoroughly combined, about 30 seconds.
4. Stir the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients until just combined.
5. Fold in the chocolate chips with a spatula.
6. Wrap the dough in wax paper and refrigerate for at least 2-3 hours.
7. While the dough is chilling, unwrap the twelve caramels and cut each one in half. 
8. Preheat oven to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Line two large baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats. Set aside.
9. Remove the dough from the refrigerator and roll the dough into balls, about 2 tablespoons of dough each. The dough may be a bit crumbly but will become smoother as you roll it.
10. Break each dough ball in half and sandwich a piece of caramel between the two haves. Smooth the two halves together by rolling the dough between your hands to make a smooth ball. Make sure the caramels are completely sealed inside. Place the balls on the baking sheet leaving at least 2 inches in between each cookie. Flatten the balls slightly with your hand to help them spread.
11. Bake for 10 - 12 minutes or until the edges are lightly browned. Allow the cookies to cool for at least 10 minutes before transferring them to a wire rack to cool completely.

Notes

• Make sure all of the ingredients are at room temperature. This ensures the ingredients mix evenly and will give you the best final texture. To quickly bring the eggs to room temperature, place the whole eggs in a bowl of warm water for 10-15 minutes.

• You could use regular chocolate chips or chopped semi-sweet chocolate, but I found mini chocolate chips easier to use when wrapping dough around pieces of caramel.
• Refrigerate the dough for 2-3 hours to allow the flour to fully hydrate and the butter to solidify which will keep the cookies from spreading too much.
• Use a cookie scoop for evenly portioned cookies. Take the guesswork out of portioning cookies by using a cookie scoop to make sure each cookie is the same size.
• Alternatively, you could cut the block of cookie dough into even pieces with a knife.
• These are my favorite baking sheets for cookies. I consider them one of my secrets to perfectly baked cookies.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

24

Serving Size:

1
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 169Total Fat: 10gSaturated Fat: 4gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 4gCholesterol: 26mgSodium: 144mgCarbohydrates: 19gFiber: 1gSugar: 8gProtein: 3g

This information is provided as a courtesy and is an estimate only. This information comes from an online calculator. Although raspberriesandkohlrabi.com attempts to provide accurate nutritional information, these figures are only estimates.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Looking For More Dessert Recipes?

• Fresh Apple Cake
• Honeycomb Candy
• Nutella Brownies
• Hazelnut Creme Brulee
• Hazelnut Brittle

Thanks for Reading!

Please remember to Like, Share, Tweet, & Pin this Post.

I publish new recipes every week! Sign up for my email newsletter to be the first to know when new recipes are published.

If you try this recipe, let me know! Leave a comment and rate it! You can also snap a picture and post it on Facebook be sure to tag me @RaspberriesandKohlrabi.